Siding With the New Adult Book Category
First, I don’t think the industry is “desperate” for creating this genre. A desperate publisher would force their writers to change their stories to fit one of the already existing genres/categories (because already existing genres/categories ARE easier to sell). I know this because it’s what agents tried to get me to do with The Forever Girl. “Can you make it MORE adult?” “Can you re-write this as a Young Adult novel?” “This is between Adult and Young Adult. Pick one.”
So is it desperate to care enough about staying true to your story to NOT want to conform? For me, I felt like it would have been more desperate to change my story and characters just so I could fit in a neat little box. Besides, from what I’ve gathered, people DO want to read books like this.
And how, exactly, does this make the BOOK industry desperate?
And what is with attacking readers who like reading this genre? If a reader wants to read about snails on a sandwich, that’s what they want. If we have that, we should let them know. Whether you charge $0.99 for your book or $9.99 for your book, a reader deserves to get what they think they’re paying for. Simple as that.
Now I do understand this one authors argument about shoe-horning genres. That said, I don’t see it being about forcing a book to be New Adult. It’s more about having a way to let the reader know what to expect (in case they may or may not like that). If you don’t fit into YA or squarely into Adult, you now have a way of saying, “Hey, this is what to expect from my book. No, it’s not quite adult, but it’s not appropriate for YAs either.”
(And by “not appropriate” I mean that ONLY in the sense that, in the society I live in, parents can be a little strict about what their kids read. Some don’t want their 13-year-olds reading about foreplay and sex. Whether children/teens should be allowed to decide this for themselves is another issue entirely, and I know a lot of teens who WOULDN’T want to read this stuff, so it’s also our job to let them know that our books do cross the YA threshold, even if they don’t seem “entirely adult” at first.)
What it comes down to isn’t dictating what people read. “
Here, you’re a YA, read this YA book.” No. It’s about letting them know WHAT TO EXPECT between the covers so they can decide for themselves and spend their money in a way that will make them happy. If you don’t want to read an adult novel that has a slightly more YA tone, then you don’t want to read New Adult. Wouldn’t you rather know in advance that a book won’t be “adult enough” for your tastes, IF that’s important to you? Or let’s say that you’re looking for a Young Adult novel because you prefer certain things fade to black. How upset would you be if you bought a book tagged as YA that shows foreplay and sex in an adult manner?
It’d be inappropriate and irresponsible for me to label my book as Young Adult. It’d also be inconsiderate to say the first book in my series is entirely adult. And I’m not the only author out there in this boat. Do we conform to the pre-existing genre boxes, or do we make room for ourselves and be fair to our potential readers by letting them know what to expect?
And what about those readers who express this is what they are looking for? Is it so bad to make it easier for a reader to find what they are looking for? Those readers who genre-hop (like myself) aren’t going to be hurt by genres existing. I’ve never met a Young Adult who felt patronized that the Young Adult genre exists just because they want to read Adult. Nope — they know they want to read adult, so they read it, and having the genre distinctions allows them to know which books to buy (adult) and which to avoid (young adult).
And this is where books differ from movies! See, with movies, you need parental permission to see certain movies. Books, well, lets just say as a teen I bought plenty of adult books when my mom wasn’t looking. I never felt patronized that a Young Adult genre existed. For some, it lets them know what to buy. For others, it lets them know what not to buy. It’s not like, “Hey, if you are 16, you must buy YA books.” So why would we act as though a New Adult genre would mean “Hey, you’re 22, you must buy NA books.” ???
I cannot follow the line of reasoning on that one (if one exists beyond trolling!)
I simply see it as this: If you’re looking only for YA books, you know to avoid Adult books. If you are looking only for Adult books, you know to avoid Young Adult books. What’s one more in the mix? If you don’t want a YA style with SOME Adult content, don’t buy. If that’s *exactly what you’re looking for* how much easier will it to be find now, without shuffling through piles of Adult and Young Adult books?
As I see it, I have a few things I hope to accomplish as a writer. I want to respect my readers, I want to give them something they want, and I don’t want to be misleading.
* * *
What about you? Do you read New Adult books? Do you write them? Are you losing sleep because they exist? If you are 18-35, do you feel patronized or like they are being shoved down your throat because they are geared toward your age range? Or should we do away with distinctions all together? Everyone can just dig through a hundred thousand books until they find what they really want? Or, perhaps, since the number of books is growing, do you think more distinctions (and allowing those different genres to be published) makes it easier for readers to find what they are looking and spend more time reading and doing other things and less time browsing for books?
Rebecca Hamilton writes Paranormal Fantasy, Gothic Horror, and Literary Fiction. She is represented by the ever-more-amazing Rossano Trentin of TZLA.
To purchase her books, please visit Paranormal Fantasy Books.